Oct. 4th, 2007

acroyear: (smiledon2)
Pharyngula: Don't get David Attenborough mad:
The offenses of creationists aren't always blatant: it's the sneaky erosion of science, the quiet omissions, the gradual degradation of good science where they make the most gains, and it's where they get bold and stick their heads out (like Dover) where they get slapped down. We need to be aware of the small stuff, too, because it adds up — like this effort by Dutch evangelicals to edit David Attenborough's documentaries. Some changes have to be made in translations and so forth, and the BBC does allow cuts up to about 5 minutes per hour, but the nasty thing is how targeted the cuts are at slicing out just those bits a pathologically ignorant theist would find objectionable.

I've had some people complain that we ought to reserve our outrage for the big stuff, the dramatic crap the creationists try to pull. I'm going to have to disagree. The little stuff that nibbles away at accurate information and slowly destroys the public education of science that must be confronted just as strenuously.
Of the changes they make, according to Attenborough himself:

Creationists rewrite natural history - Telegraph:
"Instead of saying "70 million years ago, something happens," they say "a very long time ago something happens". They also omit paragraphs such as: "This is inherited from my warm-blooded ancestors,"" Sir David told the Telegraph.

[...]

BBC documentaries have been made compatible with creationist views by replacing spoken English text by an adapted spoken Dutch text, or by cutting whole scenes. "Nevertheless, such sanitised documentaries are presented to the Dutch public as BBC documentaries," she [Dr Gerdien de Jong, an evolutionary biologist at Utrecht University] said.

In particular, she singled out the EO DVD "Het Leven van Zoogdieren" - The Life of Mammals. The series is presented as written and "presented by David Attenborough. Yet it is censored and Episode 10, about apes and humans, is absent. In short, he said, it appears "in a mutilated form, cutting or rephrasing all passages relevant to evolution."
It's sad, really.

Historically, Holland was the great savior of science, the one place so open and so free (and so far away from Rome and the Catholic Church) for science to prosper.  It was there that great minds like Huygens, Bernoulli, and others could confirm and defend the suppressed work being done by the Italians like Galileo and Torricelli and allow science to continue to progress through the insanely repressive 17th century counter-reformation and the incessant civil wars within the HRE.  That openness to science and invention led them to be the masters of the seas, trade, and exploration for almost a century while the rest of Europe and Britain fought their "demons".

And now, today, that once shining light of openness to science is being darkened by a new reformation dedicated to recreating that 17th century hell we fought so hard to get out of.

Profile

acroyear: (Default)
Joe's Ancient Jottings

January 2025

S M T W T F S
   1234
56789 1011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 17th, 2025 05:46 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios