I'd love to have Jesse Martin (Law & Order) on it, as he's one who easily stepped out of his "tough black cop" stereotype and did marvelously on Broadway. Similarly, Matthew Broderick and Nathan Lane are also worthy heirs to the greats before them who did the show, including Lane's predecessor in Producers, Zero Mostel.

plus, Broderick and Lane have the Disney connection (including Broderick working for them on the Music Man remake a few years back)...trouble is, that other factor: they're all probably too damn expensive now.